Buyout Chief: “It’s a sham. The banks are insolvent”

Buyout Chief: “It’s a sham. The banks are insolvent”

Posted on 14 May 2009

It’s a rare thing when insiders speak their minds publicly against the powers-that-be. Today in a global investment conference held in Qatar, an insider accused the entire US bank bailout of being a “sham”, and said it publicly at a global conference of his peers. Meet Mark Patterson, chairman of MattlinPatterson advisers, a firm which utilized the TARP program’s ‘matching funds’ to buy Flagstar Bancorp in Michigan. Patterson certainly didn’t pull any punches in blasting US Treasury Secretary, Tim Geithner’s bailout as being a deeply flawed plan which will not only ultimately fail, but is enriching Wall Street insiders in the process.

The Telegraph UK reports:

Mr Patterson said the US Treasury is out of its depth and seems to be trying to put off drastic action by pretending that the banking system is still viable.

“It’s a sham. The banks are insolvent. The US government is trying to sedate the public because they are down to the last $100bn (£66bn) of the $700bn TARP funds. They think they’re doing this for the greater good of society,” he said, speaking at the Qatar Global Investment Forum.

Mr Patterson said it would be better for the US to bite the bullet as Britain has done, accepting that crippled lenders must be nationalised. “At least the British are not hiding the bail-out,” he said.

Well said indeed, Mr. Patterson. We’d love to hear Mr. Geithner respond, but he’s off skipping through fields of green shoots, and worse yet, seems blissfully unaware that the US taxpayer is bearing most of the cost while seeing precious little of the upside. Perhaps when the last $100 billion of TARP funds has been magically transferred into private coffers, Mr. Geithner will make the hard choices we’re hoping for.

More from the Telegraph UK:

“This is not a normal recession and there will be no V-shaped recovery. The crisis has destroyed leveraged companies. We’re going to see a catastrophic increase in the number of LBO’s (leveraged buyouts) going into default because they’re knee-deep in debt and no solution exists since they can’t refinance,” he said.

“Alfa hedge funds have been making their money by gambling with excessive leverage, so the knife that cuts off leverage is going to cut off their heads as well,” he said.

Like many bears, Mr Patterson expects the great crunch to end in deliberate inflation, deemed a lesser evil than outright depression.

“The US government has thrown 29pc of GDP at this crisis compared to 8pc in the early 1930s. The Fed’s balance sheet has risen from $900bn to $2.7 trillion to bail out the system. America has to do it because the only way out is to debase the currency, but that is going to lead to some very high inflation three years down the road,” he said.

We couldn’t agree more with Mr. Patterson, and he has our sympathies for exercising good judgment, but bad luck in choosing to short this rally from the start. As our colleague Tyler Durden at Zero Hedge once said, “Anyone with any common sense is losing money in this market”. Our only hope is that more insiders speak up like Mark Patterson did before the situation gets any worse than it already is.